Order Your St. John Lutheran Johnny Appleseed Pies Here

It is too late to preorder a pie, but it may not be too late to get one.

We sold 350 apple pies this year (thinking without the festival we might have trouble selling 200) so we made some extras, knowing that there is always an extra demand once they are ready,


We finished baking and ready for pickup at West Central Coffee during normal business hours (7 am – 3 pm) from Sunday, October 11th through Sunday, October 18th. In addition, on October 11th from Noon until 6 PM, you may drive through the St John Parking lot to receive your pies in your car. A limited quantity of pies will be available for those who missed pre-ordering, first come first serve. There is free parking in the St. John Lutheran Church lot with access off of either Van Buren or Jefferson.

Seeking more information or have a question? Email pies@stjohnluth.com

Our freshly made pies should be refrigerated or frozen if they are not eaten within a few days.

Frozen pies should be fully baked before being enjoyed. I have stored some for a whole year and they were just as wonderful as fresh. (Great for Thanksgiving, as you can say “I just baked this”! and be totally truthful!)


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *